5 O'clock Club Menu
32 items in 5 sections · $0.50 – $22.00 · American Restaurant in Pewaukee, WI
5 O'clock Club’s menu lists 32 dishes and drinks, grouped into Soup of the Day, Salads and Pasta Entrees, Fish Fry, Sandwiches, and Add to Any Sandwich. Prices range from $0.50 to $22.00, and a typical item costs about $9.50. Popular choices include Soup of the Day, Grandma's Garden Salad, Deep Fried, Tenderloin Steak Sandwich, and Swiss, Mozzarella, Cheddar, American.
Soup of the Day 1
- Soup of the Day$3.95
Salads and Pasta Entrees 8
- Grandma's Garden Salad$11.00
A large mixed green salad of fresh vegetables, house croutons, fresh fruit, cottage cheese, cubed cheese and crumbled bacon
- Chicken Caesar Salad with Grilled Sliced Chicken Breast$12.50
Crisp Romaine, tossed with our own Caesar dressing. Garnished with parmesan cheese, hard cooked egg, tomatoes, Kalamata olives, house croutons and fresh fruit
- Raspberry Chicken Salad$12.50
Mixed greens tossed with our house recipe raspberry vinaigrette. Garnished with seasonal fruit, hard cooked egg, sliced red onion, tomatoes, toasted almonds and garlic-thyme croutons
- Side Salad$3.50
- Soup and Salad$7.45
- Side Caesar Salad$5.50
- Soup and Side Caesar Salad$9.45
- Steamed Vegetable Medley$14.00
Garlic butter Sauce. Angel Hair Pasta
Fish Fry 5
- Deep Fried$12.00
Lake Perch (MKT)
- Baked Cod$13.50
With Sautéed Vegetables And Pasta
- Shrimp$18.50
- Scallops$18.50
- Seafood Combo$22.00
Perch, cod, shrimp, scallops, deep fried
Sandwiches 13
- Tenderloin Steak Sandwich$16.95
Open faced on Italian bread. Grilled mushrooms and onions. Onion Rings
- The "Little Cluck" Fried Chicken Breast$9.45
Toasted wheat Kaiser bun. Lettuce, tomato slice, crunchy dill pickle spear
- Grilled "Little Cluck"$9.45
Toasted wheat Kaiser bun. Lettuce, tomato slice, crunchy dill pickle spear
- The "Un-Bun" Chicken…no Bun!$10.95
Grilled chicken. Side salad, fresh fruit and cottage cheese
- "Prospect Avenue"$10.50
Grilled chicken breast, bacon, Swiss, mozzarella, and cheddar, on grilled Italian bread
- Cod Fish Sandwich$9.50
Lettuce, tomato, lemon and tartar
- Perch Fish Sandwich$12.00
Lettuce, tomato, lemon and tartar
- 5 O'Clock "Club"$8.95
Honey smoked ham on toasted wheat bread. Lettuce, tomato and mayo
- Grilled Ham and Cheddar$8.50
A Midwest classic. On grilled Parmesan crusted Italian bread
- Super Grilled Cheese$7.75
Wisconsin sharp cheddar cheese, onions and tomato slices on thick sliced white bread
- "I'll Just Have a Burger" 8 oz.$8.50
Toasted white Kaiser bun, lettuce, tomato, raw onion and crunchy dill pickle
- The Mainstreet Burger$9.50
On toasted marble rye, with melted cheddar and grilled onions
- The "Un-Bun" Burger….No Bun!$10.95
Side salad, fresh fruit and cottage cheese
Add to Any Sandwich 5
- Swiss, Mozzarella, Cheddar, American$0.80
- Bleu Cheese$0.95
- Grilled Mushrooms$0.95
- Crispy Bacon$1.00
- Grilled Onions$0.50
How these prices compare
Based on 48 menus with 2,222 priced items from American restaurants in Wisconsin, the median menu item costs $11.00, and half of all items are priced between $7.00 and $15.00.
At 5 O'clock Club the median listed price is $9.50, lower than the typical $11.00 for American restaurants in Wisconsin.
| Item | Here | Typical |
|---|---|---|
| Soup of the Day | $3.95 | $6.00 |
| Side Salad | $3.50 | $3.75 |
Typical prices are calculated from 48 menus in our guide.
Menu items and prices are provided for information and may have changed (last updated April 2026). Allergen information is not included – please ask the restaurant.